top of page
Search

The Mad Monk's Messages: How an Ordinary Inheritance Revealed an Extraordinary Secret

  • Writer: Philippe Smolarski
    Philippe Smolarski
  • Mar 6
  • 6 min read

There are days when I tell myself I should write a book about the strange objects people ask me to authenticate. Then I remember that no one would believe me. Especially not after what happened two weeks ago.


The Innocent Email

It all started as usual: me, my too-strong coffee, and my email inbox full of requests to evaluate "authentic" Picasso paintings bought at flea markets (spoiler: they never are).

Then came this message from Jean-Claude, 78, who lives in a small country house. I quote: "Hello, I found these old Russian letters in my grandmother's belongings. She was Russian and fled during the revolution. I don't read Russian. Are they worth anything?"

Three blurry photos were attached. I almost ignored them. Thank God I didn't.


When I Choked On My Coffee

As soon as I opened the attachments, my heart skipped a beat. As a Russian speaker and passionate about Russian history, I immediately noticed something extraordinary about these documents.

"This can't be possible," I murmured, practically spitting my coffee onto my screen.

Because before me was what strongly resembled the signature of Grigori Efimovich Rasputin. Yes, THAT Rasputin. The mystical, legendary-bearded man who bewitched the Russian imperial family and became one of the most controversial figures in modern history.

Of course, I couldn't yet confirm the authenticity of these documents from simple photos, but the similarities with other Rasputin signatures I had studied were enough to trigger all my professional alarms.


A Video Call for the History Books

I immediately asked Jean-Claude if he would agree to a video call. To my great surprise, he responded in less than five minutes (which defies all stereotypes about elderly people and technology).

"Bonjour monsieur " he told me with a warm smile. "Do you have news about grandmother's papers?"

"Jean-Claude," I began, striving to keep a calm and professional tone, "can you show me these letters more closely?"

He held his phone with some difficulty in front of three documents yellowed by time. Letters written in a rustic, clumsy, and urgent Cyrillic handwriting. I took screenshots and immediately sent them to my friend, a Russian history specialist at the CNRS.


The Great Revelation

"Do you know a historical figure named Rasputin?" I asked.

"Like the vodka brand?" he replied, looking innocent.

Oh my God. I realized Jean-Claude had no idea of the potential value of what he had.

"From what I can see in these photos, these letters bear a troubling resemblance to the handwriting and signature of Grigori Rasputin. I cannot guarantee their authenticity without thorough expertise, but the visual clues are convincing enough to warrant a serious investigation."

I paused to allow Jean-Claude to digest this information.

"Rasputin was an incredibly influential figure to the Russian imperial family before the revolution. A mystic, a healer, and according to some, the real power behind the throne in the last years of the Empire."

"Really? Grandmother didn't talk much about Russia. She just said she had been around important people."

Important people. The understatement of the century.


The Letters to Decipher

Thanks to my knowledge of Russian, I was able to do a first reading of the letters' content from the photos. If these documents prove authentic after examination, their content would be fascinating:

First letter: The author gives spiritual advice to a woman named Elena Ivanovna (probably Jean-Claude's grandmother). He refers with troubling familiarity to "the icon of Saint Nicholas in the right corner of your room" and suggests how to arrange sacred objects to "strengthen divine protection." The fact that he seems to know the details of her room suggests an intriguing closeness.

Second letter: More practical, the letter mentions specific medicinal herbs that the author is having prepared for Elena. "My secretary will personally bring you the mixture that will relieve your migraines," it reads, with precise instructions for their preparation. If it's from Rasputin, this letter would confirm his well-known role as a healer.

Third letter: Dated November 20, 1916, less than a month before Rasputin's assassination, the author writes with a certain urgency: "Times are difficult, and the winds of destiny blow intensely. Eyes are on me, but I remain devoted to my mission. You want to meet me, and I will ensure that happens. Stay alert for my signal, as it is essential to act cautiously. May God keep you (S Bogom)." Premonitory, if one thinks about what would follow.


Jean-Claude And His Mysterious Grandmother


"Jean-Claude," I asked, "did your grandmother leave you anything else from her past in Russia?"

He shrugged. "Just an old icon and a jewelry box that I gave to my daughter. She always said that true treasures were memories."

At that moment, I wondered if Jean-Claude had innocently given Russian imperial jewels to his daughter for her birthday.

"Do you know how your grandmother left Russia?"

"Through Finland, I believe. She arrived in France in 1918 with just a small suitcase. She always said she had been lucky."

Lucky. Or perhaps with the help of a controversial mystic who had foreseen his own fall and that of the empire he had so influenced.


The Million-Euro Question

After my preliminary examination of the photos, I called Jean-Claude back to explain the situation.

"Jean-Claude," I began, "based on what I can see, these letters could be extremely important. However, I must be very clear: we cannot yet confirm their authenticity with certainty from simple photographs."

"What does that mean?" he asked.

"It means we need to proceed with a complete examination. Paper analysis to verify its age, tests on the ink to confirm it's from the period, thorough graphological expertise to compare the handwriting with other authentic Rasputin documents. Only after all these verifications can we assess their potential value."

A silence. "And... how much could they be worth, if it's true?"

I chose my words carefully. "If - and I emphasize if - these documents prove authentic after complete expertise, personal letters from Rasputin could reach 75,000 to 150,000 euros at auction. But we're not there yet."

"That's more than my car," he murmured.

The understatement of the century, part two.


The Continuation of the Story:

"Jean-Claude," I said, "I'm going to help you organize the complete expertise of these documents. This isn't something we can do ourselves at Moon Rabbit Art."

"Really? But you just told me you speak Russian?" he asked, visibly disappointed.

"Speaking the language is one thing, but authenticating such important historical documents is another. The authenticity of documents attributed to Rasputin is notoriously difficult to establish, precisely because of his fame. Many counterfeits have been circulating for a century."

I continued: "We'll need to consult several specialists: an expert in old paper and inks to precisely date the materials, a specialist in Russian historical graphology who can analyze the distinctive writing characteristics of Rasputin - such as these specific spelling mistakes and this grammatical simplicity typical of his lack of formal education. We'll also need a historian who is an expert on Rasputin to analyze the content in its historical context."

Jean-Claude looked perplexed. "All that?"

"Of course. When it comes to potentially such valuable documents, it's essential not to settle for a superficial analysis. Did you know that Rasputin's writing is so distinctly... imperfect... that it could almost serve as a signature by itself? His simple and direct style, as well as his frequent grammatical errors, are crucial elements for authentication."

Jean-Claude nodded. "And how much will this expertise cost?"

I smiled. "Much less than what these letters could be worth if they prove authentic. Consider it an investment."

The letters are currently being examined in a specialized laboratory in Paris. Jean-Claude receives regular updates, as do I. Each new email from the laboratory fills me with excitement.


Conclusion:

At Moon Rabbit Art, we like to remind our clients that history can hide in the most unexpected places. These potential Rasputin letters spent decades in a simple shoebox under a bed, their historical importance unknown even to their owner.

This story perfectly illustrates why professional expertise is crucial in the field of antiques and historical documents. Especially when it comes to a figure as famous as Rasputin, where:

The writing must be examined for its characteristic simplicity and typical grammatical errors

The paper and ink must exactly match the period

The content must be in accordance with what we know about the person and the historical context

We wait to see what the experts will determine for Jean-Claude's letters. Perhaps they will be authenticated as true relics of one of the most mysterious figures in Russian history. Or perhaps they will prove to be brilliant forgeries. Either way, it's the rigorous authentication process that will give us the answer.

So, the next time you clean out grandma's attic, take a look at those old papers before throwing them away. And if you find something interesting, don't hesitate to contact us at Moon Rabbit Art. We don't guarantee they'll be letters from Rasputin... but who knows?

As we often say: "Treasures don't shout their value. They whisper their story to those who take the time to listen."



P.S. Jean-Claude has promised to check that jewelry box he gave to his daughter. I subtly suggested he NOT mention our conversation before we can take a look. Just in case his daughter is unknowingly wearing jewelry that belonged to the imperial court.

 
 
 

Kommentit


bottom of page